How to know your therapist is the right fit for you

Research consistently shows that one of the strongest predictors of successful therapy isn’t a specific technique or treatment approach. It’s the relationship between the therapist and the client.

And that relationship can feel especially important when you’re sober-curious, cutting back on drinking, or newly sober.

Maybe you don’t consider yourself someone who has a “drinking problem.” You just know you’re tired of waking up anxious after a night out, making rules about how much you’re going to drink and breaking them, or spending your weekends recovering when you want to go to the gym, see friends, or get things done.

Or you’ve already stopped drinking and discovered that not drinking is only part of it. Now you’re figuring out how to go to dinner when everyone else orders cocktails, date without meeting for drinks, deal with work stress without pouring a glass of wine, or sit with anxiety instead of trying to shut it off.

That is incredibly vulnerable territory.

A strong therapeutic relationship gives you a place to talk about all of it without feeling like you need to prove that your drinking was “bad enough” to deserve support. It can create the trust and safety needed to be honest about the parts you’re still figuring out, including the days when you miss drinking or aren’t sure what you want your relationship with alcohol to look like.

Psychiatrist Irvin Yalom, the founder of Existential Therapy, famously said, “It’s the relationship that heals.”

Existential therapy emphasizes self-awareness and personal responsibility as you figure out how you want to live your life. It also pays attention to what happens in the “here and now” between the therapist and client.

Many of the patterns that show up in your life eventually show up in therapy, too. You could be used to saying you’re fine when you’re not. You worry about disappointing people, avoid difficult conversations, or assume you’re being judged even when no one has said anything personal.

Therapy gives you and your therapist an opportunity to notice those patterns together and practice something different.

But if the relationship is such an important part of therapy, how do you know whether your therapist is the right fit?

Step 1: Does the relationship feel collaborative?

Collaboration means your therapist works with you to figure out what you want instead of deciding what your relationship with alcohol should look like for you.

Maybe you're exploring what it looks like to stop drinking completely or you’re taking a break and seeing how you feel. You could also be questioning whether alcohol is really a problem but really not understanding the role it’s playing in your life.

You should be able to be honest about that with your therapist.

If you tell your therapist, “I’m not ready to say I’ll never drink again,” therapy can help you get curious about what’s happening.

Why is it easy to decide you’re not drinking on Tuesday but so much harder when your friends text about happy hour on Friday? Why does work stress immediately make you think about having a drink? What happens when you’re at a wedding and everyone around you is drinking? Why do you feel like you need alcohol to loosen up on a date?

The goal isn’t for your therapist to make those decisions for you or tell you which decision to make but rather, it’s to help you understand yourself well enough to make them for yourself. Your therapist is to help support and create a spacer that builds understanding of why we make the decisions we do.

Step 2: Do they focus on what’s happening in your life right now?

Understanding your past can be an important part of therapy, but therapy can't stay stuck there.

You may want to understand why alcohol became such an effective coping strategy in the first place. At the same time, you probably need help with what happens on a Wednesday night when you’ve had a terrible day at work and your brain immediately goes, a glass of wine would make this better.

Or what happens when you stop drinking and realize you don’t know how to relax.

Or when you go out with friends and suddenly feel painfully aware that everyone has a drink in their hand except you.

Or when you start wondering whether certain friendships still work when you’re not spending every weekend drinking together.

A good therapist helps you connect your bigger patterns to the situations happening in your actual life.

They’ll also notice what happens between the two of you.

Things to consider how you show up in therapy are: you minimize how much you drank because you’re worried they’ll judge you, you automatically say everything is going great because you don’t want to disappoint them, or you had a drink after deciding you wouldn’t and spend half the session trying to avoid bringing it up.

Those hesitations matter.

An effective therapist can notice them with curiosity and compassion rather than making you feel ashamed. But it is also on you to share the information so they can be curious and compassionate.

Step 3: Do you feel a genuine human connection?

Feeling understood does not mean your therapist agrees with every decision you make.

It means you can tell the truth. “I drank this weekend and I’m frustrated with myself" or “Part of me really misses it" or “I know I feel better when I don’t drink, but I also hate feeling like the boring person at dinner.”

You can talk about the fact that dating sober feels awkward, your partner still drinks, your friends keep asking why you aren’t drinking, or you’re worried people are going to assume you had a serious drinking problem if you tell them you stopped.

A strong therapeutic relationship is built on warmth, curiosity, consistency, and genuine investment in your progress.

There’s also an important difference between empathy and enabling. A good therapist won’t shame you for drinking or for struggling, but they also won’t avoid helping you look at patterns that are hurting you.

If every Monday you tell yourself you’re going to take a break from alcohol and every Friday you end up drinking again, therapy can be a place to understand why that keeps happening instead of simply deciding you need more willpower and when further treatment steps are needed.

Step 4: Can you talk about the relationship itself?

One of the healthiest signs of a strong therapeutic relationship is that you can talk about the relationship with your therapist. Your therapist isn't perfect and could have said said something about your drinking that felt judgmental, or it feels felt like they were pushing sobriety before you were ready, and even when you're newly sober and feel like they're focusing so much on alcohol that everything else about you has disappeared.

They could also have challenged you on something and you left the session annoyed, only to realize there was something important underneath that reaction.

You should be able to bring those things back into the room and if you do, noticing how your therapist responds to those dynamics.

Therapy should be built on mutual respect. Your therapist brings clinical expertise, but you are the expert on your own life. The work is most effective when both people actively participate. Feeling uncomfortable at times is a normal part of therapy and life. That's what makes therapy so useful, you can practice the skills in real time before trying them out in the "real world."

A therapist who welcomes those conversations without becoming defensive gives you an opportunity to practice something many people haven’t had enough experience with: being honest in a relationship, having a difficult conversation, and discovering that the relationship can survive it.

Finding the Right Therapist When You’re Changing Your Relationship With Alcohol

You may be doing well at work, paying your bills, maintaining relationships, going to the gym, and handling everything you're supposed to handle. But you may still be wondering why alcohol is taking up so much space in your life.

You don't have to wait until your life falls apart to talk about your relationship with alcohol. Our society and culture is changing its relationship with alcohol, so alcoholism doesn't exactly look like completely losing your career, family, or self to have an abusive relationship with it.

And if you're newly sober, therapy doesn't have to be only about not drinking. It can also be about figuring out who you are, what you want your relationships to look like, how you want to take care of yourself, and what you want your life to feel like when alcohol isn't your default way of coping, celebrating, connecting, or shutting your brain off.

If you're wondering whether your therapist is the right fit, don't just ask, “Do I like them?” Ask yourself:

• Do I feel safe enough to tell them the truth about my drinking? Or even tell them why you haven't been honest about the level of drinking? 
• Can I admit when I'm struggling without feeling ashamed? But also acknowledge when whether or not the therapist is making us feel ashamed or the situation at hand.
• Can I talk about missing alcohol or feeling unsure about sobriety? Is there space for me to connect with the grief of not having anymore alcohol?
• Do I feel like they're helping me figure out what I want rather than deciding for me? Does it feel collaborative?
• Can I tell them when something they said didn't sit right with me? Or do I keep everything to myself?

The therapeutic relationship isn't just the setting where healing happens, it's part of the healing itself.

Finding the right fit isn't about finding a perfect therapist. It's about finding someone you can be honest with while you figure out what you want your relationship with alcohol, yourself, and the people in your life to look like from here.

‍

‍